Home NEWS Finland Extends Controversial Border Law Until 2028 as SDP Faces Internal Dispute

Finland Extends Controversial Border Law Until 2028 as SDP Faces Internal Dispute

0
Finland’s controversial border law will remain in force until the end of 2028 after parliament voted overwhelmingly to extend the legislation, despite disagreements within the opposition Social Democratic Party (SDP) over whether its members should support the measure.

The extension was approved on Wednesday by 170 votes to 19, with 10 MPs absent. The decision followed an internal agreement within the SDP requiring its MPs to vote in favour, even though several members had asked for permission to oppose the legislation or abstain.

Finland Extends Controversial Border Law Until 2028 as SDP Faces Internal Dispute

Introduced in July 2024, the law gives Finland the power to restrict the acceptance of asylum applications and turn away people arriving at its borders under exceptional circumstances involving migration organised by a foreign state. The legislation was introduced after Finland accused Russia of facilitating the arrival of asylum seekers at its eastern border in autumn 2023, an incident Finnish authorities viewed as an attempt to put political pressure on the country.

The law has not been used since its introduction. Any decision to activate it would require a separate government decision, meaning the extension does not automatically change how Finland’s borders or asylum procedures operate.

Prime Minister Petteri Orpo defended the decision, saying the security situation along Finland’s eastern border had not improved enough to justify allowing the legislation to expire. He also thanked opposition parties that supported the extension.

The governing parties received support from the SDP, Centre Party and Movement Now. However, the Left Alliance and Greens voted against the measure, as did Eva Biaudet of the governing Swedish People’s Party.

Although the legislation passed with broad parliamentary support, the vote brought disagreements within the SDP into public view. Six party MPs had asked to vote against the extension or abstain, but the parliamentary group leadership did not grant their request.

Former prime minister Antti Rinne, who ultimately voted in favour, criticised the party leadership after the parliamentary session. Speaking to journalists, he said MPs had not been forced to vote for the legislation but had faced pressure to go against their personal convictions.

In comments reported by Yle, Rinne questioned how the party had handled the disagreement and criticised the pressure placed on MPs. He also pointed out that the SDP had previously allowed members to vote against the legislation, making the latest decision a departure from its earlier approach.

According to Helsingin Sanomat, Rinne directed his criticism at both party chair Antti Lindtman and the leadership of the SDP parliamentary group.

Nasima Razmyar, the party’s first vice-chairperson, also expressed reservations about the decision. Although she voted in favour of the extension, she told Ilta-Sanomat that doing so went against her convictions.

“This is by far the most difficult issue of my political career,” Razmyar said, adding that her position on the legislation had not changed.

Razmyar arrived in Finland as a refugee in 1992 and has consistently questioned the law. She argued that Finland should pursue a common European Union approach to the situation rather than rely on the national legislation.

She also criticised the SDP leadership for not doing enough to defend MPs who opposed the law after political opponents accused them of acting in Russia’s interests. According to Razmyar, the party should have stood up more clearly for members who had expressed reservations.

Rinne and Razmyar both voted in favour of the extension, while SDP MPs Krista Kiuru, Elisa Gebhard and Matias Mäkynen were absent from the vote.

The disagreement was not limited to MPs who had opposed the law. According to Ilta-Sanomat, some SDP members who supported the extension also questioned the leadership’s handling of the issue, arguing that enforcing a common voting position had created unnecessary tension within the party.

ALSO READ: Finnish Union Pro Proposes 32-Hour Working Week Without Salary Cuts as Riikka Purra Rejects Idea

The dispute is linked to a decision made at the SDP party congress in May, when members agreed to support the legislation for the time being. The parliamentary leadership treated that position as binding when MPs were asked to vote on the extension.

Beyond the political disagreement, the legislation has also faced legal scrutiny. Experts consulted during the legislative process questioned whether the law is compatible with Finland’s Constitution and its international human rights obligations.

The government, however, maintains that the possibility of migration being used as a political instrument against Finland remains a serious security concern. With parliament’s approval, the exceptional border powers will remain available to the government until the end of 2028, even though the legislation has yet to be activated.

Editorial note: The legislation was previously extended in 2025, from its original one-year period to the end of 2026. The November 2026 vote is therefore its second extension. Parliament’s Constitutional Law Committee also concluded that the proposed extension could proceed as an exception to the Constitution, while emphasising the need to monitor its necessity and the security situation.