Home NEWS Five EU Countries Plan Rwanda Deportation Hubs for Rejected Asylum Seekers in...

Five EU Countries Plan Rwanda Deportation Hubs for Rejected Asylum Seekers in 2027

0
Five EU countries are planning to send rejected asylum seekers to Rwanda from 2027 under a proposed migration agreement that would establish a return centre outside the European Union.

Denmark, Austria, Germany, the Netherlands and Greece announced the partnership on Monday, describing it as an effort to strengthen the enforcement of deportation decisions against migrants who have exhausted their right to remain in Europe. The proposed arrangement would create the EU’s first return hub outside the bloc, although several details, including its operating costs and legal framework, remain under negotiation.

Five EU Countries Plan Rwanda Deportation Hubs for Rejected Asylum Seekers in 2027

The initial facility is expected to accommodate approximately 100 people at a time. Unlike a conventional detention centre, those transferred to Rwanda would reportedly be allowed to move freely within the country, with the expectation that they would eventually integrate into local communities and seek employment.

Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen described the agreement as a major change in European migration policy. Speaking at the announcement in Vienna alongside Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker, representatives of the participating countries and Rwanda’s Vincent Biruta, she said the arrangement would help governments regain control of migration and reduce incentives for irregular entry into Europe.

The five countries intend to begin with a small pilot project before considering an expansion. However, the scale of any future programme will depend partly on whether the participating governments can overcome legal challenges that could prevent deportations from going ahead.

The arrangement is intended for people who have no legal right to remain in the participating EU countries and whose return decisions can be enforced. It is not designed to transfer people whose asylum applications are still being considered. Unaccompanied minors will be excluded, and the initial phase will focus on single adult men.

The countries will also apply different criteria when deciding who is transferred. The Netherlands plans to prioritise men from countries in the same region as Rwanda. Germany, meanwhile, is expected to focus on people who refuse to cooperate with efforts to establish their identities and who come from countries that are unwilling to accept their nationals back.

The proposed system is intended to offer an alternative when a person’s country of origin cannot be persuaded to accept their return. Once in Rwanda, migrants would have the opportunity to settle, access the labour market, education and healthcare, and seek legal residence. They could also choose to return to their home countries or move to another country where they have permission to live.

The length of time people would spend in the facility has not been established. This raises questions about what happens to individuals who cannot or do not wish to settle in Rwanda and whose countries of origin refuse to receive them.

The EU border agency Frontex is not expected to take part in the initial deportations. This is despite a European Commission proposal to expand the agency’s powers to include a greater role in organising returns.

The financial arrangements have yet to be finalised. The five European countries will cover the costs of transferring migrants to Rwanda and providing temporary accommodation. However, officials have not announced a budget for the pilot project. The countries are expected to work with Rwanda and international organisations to agree on the practical arrangements before the first transfers take place.

The proposed partnership has already attracted criticism from human rights advocates and political representatives. Concerns centre on whether Rwanda can provide adequate protection for people transferred from Europe and whether the arrangement will comply with international human rights obligations.

ALSO READ: UN Countries Face Crucial Decision on International Rules for ‘Killer Robots’

French Green lawmaker Mélissa Camara criticised the agreement, describing it as a “shame” and accusing the participating governments of crossing a moral line by entering into an arrangement with Rwanda’s government. Other critics have questioned the decision to transfer people to a country with which they may have no personal or family connection.

The five governments maintain that the programme will operate in accordance with European and international law. The Dutch government has also said it intends to involve international organisations, including the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and the International Organization for Migration, in developing the arrangements.

However, legal questions remain. Under European human rights law, governments cannot transfer individuals to another country where there are substantial grounds to believe they would face torture, inhuman or degrading treatment, or other serious violations of their fundamental rights. Each case must be assessed against the relevant legal protections, including the principle of non-refoulement, which prevents refugees from being returned to places where they face persecution or serious harm.

The proposed arrangement also brings back scrutiny of Rwanda’s previous migration agreement with the United Kingdom. In November 2023, the UK Supreme Court ruled that the British government’s plan to transfer asylum seekers to Rwanda was unlawful. The court found substantial grounds to believe that people sent there could be wrongly returned to countries where they faced persecution because of weaknesses in Rwanda’s asylum system.

The British and European proposals are not identical. The UK plan involved transferring people whose asylum claims were to be considered in Rwanda, while the new EU arrangement is intended for people who have already exhausted their legal options to remain in the participating member states. Nevertheless, the earlier ruling is likely to feature in legal arguments over the new scheme.

The EU framework allowing member states to establish return hubs outside the bloc also sets conditions for the countries selected to host them. These arrangements must respect international human rights standards and principles. Whether Rwanda meets those requirements in practice, and whether the proposed safeguards will withstand legal scrutiny, will be central to the programme’s implementation.

For now, the five countries are moving ahead with preparations for a pilot facility, with the first transfers planned for 2027. The negotiations will determine how the system operates, but its legality and the treatment of people transferred to Rwanda are likely to remain major points of dispute.

The Dutch government has confirmed that the initial arrangement will cover accommodation and other related costs, with the participating countries sharing the financial responsibility.

The legal concerns are significant because the European human rights framework does not allow governments to transfer individuals to countries where they face a real risk of serious rights violations. The principle of non-refoulement also prohibits returning people to places where they could face persecution or other serious harm.

The UK Supreme Court’s 2023 ruling is particularly relevant. In its judgment, the court found that the British government’s Rwanda policy was unlawful because of substantial grounds for believing that asylum seekers transferred there could be sent back to countries where they faced persecution.

Although the proposed EU arrangement differs from the former British scheme because it targets people who have exhausted their legal options to remain in Europe, the previous judgment could still become relevant in future legal challenges.

The European governments now face the task of turning their political agreement into an operational programme that meets the legal requirements. Whether the Rwanda return hub can proceed as planned will depend on the final agreement, the safeguards put in place and the outcome of any legal challenges.